Wrapping vs Replacement: Cost Comparison GuideCall Now on - 0115-824-4201
To Arrange A FREE Consultation 
|
|
Understanding Your Kitchen Update Options
When your kitchen doors look tired but the cabinets underneath are still solid, you've got two main choices - wrap the existing doors or replace them completely. Both can transform how your kitchen looks, but they work very differently and suit different situations.
We've been offering both services for over 8 years now, so we've got proper long-term data on costs, performance, and customer satisfaction. The honest answer is that sometimes wrapping is brilliant, sometimes replacement is better, and occasionally we recommend doing nothing at all.
The key is matching the solution to your specific situation rather than just choosing the cheapest option.
Kitchen Wrapping: The Details
What Can Actually Be Wrapped
Solid wood doors wrap beautifully if they're in good structural condition. The vinyl adheres well to wood and follows the grain texture naturally.
MDF doors with painted finishes work well for wrapping as long as the paint isn't flaking or the MDF isn't swollen from moisture damage.
Simple raised panel designs can be wrapped successfully. Complex mouldings and deep profiles are much more difficult and often don't look convincing.
Flat panel doors are perfect for wrapping - clean lines, easy application, and professional results.
The family in Carlton had 1990s oak doors that were structurally perfect but looked dated. Wrapping them in a contemporary wood-effect finish gave them a completely fresh kitchen for a fraction of replacement cost.
What Wrapping Can't Fix
Damaged or warped doors won't improve with wrapping. The vinyl follows the existing surface, so any problems become more obvious rather than hidden.
Doors with complex profiles where vinyl can't follow curves properly. Attempt to wrap intricate mouldings and you'll get visible creases and lifted edges.
Moisture-damaged MDF that's swollen or soft. Wrapping won't solve the underlying problem and won't last on compromised surfaces.
Very old doors with failing joints need structural repair before wrapping becomes viable.
We always assess existing doors honestly before recommending wrapping. No point applying vinyl to doors that need replacing anyway.
The Professional Wrapping Process
Surface preparation involves thorough cleaning, light sanding to provide key, and filling any small imperfections. This prep work determines how good the final result looks.
Template creation ensures vinyl pieces are cut precisely for each door size. Hand-cutting during application leads to visible joints and poor finishing.
Application technique requires specialist tools and experience. Heating the vinyl correctly, avoiding air bubbles, and achieving tight corners takes skill.
Edge finishing separates amateur from professional work. Clean, tight edges that won't lift over time require proper technique and quality materials.
The whole process takes 2-3 days for an average kitchen - much quicker than replacement but still needs doing properly.
Quality Levels in Wrapping Materials
Budget vinyl films cost less but often fail within 3-4 years. Poor adhesive systems and thin materials don't cope with kitchen environments.
Mid-range options offer reasonable performance for 5-7 years. Suitable for rental properties or short-term solutions.
Premium architectural films from 3M or Avery last 8-12 years with proper application. These materials are designed for demanding environments and daily use.
We only use premium materials because we want customers still happy with their choice 8 years later. Cheap vinyl that fails after 3 years costs more in the long run.
Realistic Wrapping Costs
Labour costs typically run £80-120 per door depending on size and complexity. Drawer fronts cost £40-60 each.
Material costs vary dramatically by quality. Budget vinyl might add £10 per door, premium materials add £25-40 per door.
Additional costs include new handles (existing holes might not suit new design), edge trim replacement, and sometimes new hinges if old ones are worn.
Total project costs for an average 12-door kitchen range from £1,200-2,500 depending on material quality and additional work needed.
The family in West Bridgford spent £1,800 wrapping their 15-door kitchen in premium wood-effect vinyl. Two years later, it still looks like new and they're delighted with the value.
Door Replacement: The Investment
What's Included in Replacement
New cabinet doors manufactured to your exact specifications and style preferences. No compromise on design or quality.
New drawer fronts that match perfectly and can be sized differently from existing ones if needed.
Complete hardware upgrade including new hinges, drawer runners, and handles. Everything works like new because it is new.
Professional fitting with precise adjustment and alignment. Doors hang perfectly because they're made specifically for your cabinets.
Quality guarantees typically 10-25 years depending on materials chosen. Long-term peace of mind about performance.
Material and Style Options
18mm thick doors provide substantial feel and long-term durability. Much better than the 15mm thickness common in budget ranges.
Soft-close hinges as standard on quality replacements. Transforms how the kitchen feels to use daily.
German-manufactured components offer superior quality and longevity compared to budget alternatives.
Unlimited style choices from traditional raised panels to contemporary handleless designs. No restrictions based on existing door profiles.
The family in Arnold replaced their 1980s doors with contemporary flat-panel designs. The transformation was dramatic - same kitchen layout but completely modern appearance.
Quality Construction Standards
Furniture-grade materials designed for decades of daily use. No shortcuts on internal construction or edge banding.
Precision manufacturing ensures perfect fit and long-term stability. Doors stay aligned and gaps remain consistent.
Professional spray finishes provide durability that hand-painting can't match. Smooth, even coverage that lasts years.
Complete quality control from manufacture through installation. Every component checked before fitting.
Replacement Cost Reality
Quality doors typically cost £150-300 each depending on size, style, and materials chosen.
Drawer fronts range from £80-150 each for quality construction.
Hardware upgrades add £50-100 per door when including soft-close hinges and quality runners.
Installation and adjustment usually included in door supplier pricing.
Total project costs for 12-door kitchens range from £3,500-7,000 depending on specification chosen.
More expensive initially, but the quality difference is dramatic and long-lasting.
Side-by-Side Performance Comparison
Appearance Quality
Wrapping can look excellent when done professionally with quality materials. Wood-effect wraps are particularly convincing and hard to distinguish from real wood.
Replacement offers perfect finish quality and unlimited design options. No compromises based on existing door shapes or conditions.
Winner depends on expectations. Wrapping can look brilliant, but replacement allows complete design freedom.
Durability Over Time
Quality wrapping lasts 8-12 years with proper care. Premium materials maintain their appearance well through normal kitchen use.
Door replacement typically lasts 20+ years. Quality construction and materials provide decades of reliable performance.
Repair options differ significantly. Wrapped doors usually need complete re-wrapping if damaged. Quality replacement doors can often be repaired or refinished.
Daily Performance
Wrapped doors perform exactly like the original doors underneath. If the originals were solid and well-hung, wrapped versions work perfectly.
New doors work better than originals because everything is new - hinges, runners, and mounting points all perform like new installations.
Weight differences can affect performance. Wrapped doors keep original weight, while replacement doors might be lighter or heavier depending on construction.
Style Flexibility
Wrapping is limited by existing door shapes. You can change colour and texture but not fundamental design.
Replacement offers unlimited style options. Complete freedom to change from traditional to contemporary or vice versa.
Future changes are easier with replacement doors. New handles, different finishes, or style updates are all possible.
When Wrapping Makes Perfect Sense
Solid Existing Doors
If your cabinet boxes and doors are structurally sound but just look dated, wrapping can be brilliant. Quality 1990s oak doors wrapped in contemporary finishes look stunning.
Budget-Conscious Updates
When the budget is tight but visual impact is important, quality wrapping delivers dramatic transformation for much less than replacement.
Rental Property Improvements
Landlords often prefer wrapping because it provides tenant appeal without the full investment of replacement. Good quality wrapping lasts long enough for multiple tenancies.
Quick Transformation Timeline
Wrapping takes 2-3 days compared to 3-4 weeks for replacement. Perfect when you need results quickly.
Specific Style Requirements
Some wood-effect and textured finishes are actually better achieved through wrapping than replacement. Premium vinyl films can create effects impossible with painted doors.
The family in Sherwood wrapped their solid oak doors with a lighter wood-effect finish. The result looked exactly like expensive new timber doors but cost 60% less.
When Replacement is the Better Choice
Poor Condition Existing Doors
Warped, damaged, or moisture-affected doors won't improve with wrapping. Replacement provides a fresh start with guaranteed quality.
Desire for Modern Features
Soft-close hinges, integrated handles, or contemporary profiles require replacement. These features can't be added through wrapping.
Long-Term Investment Thinking
If you're planning to stay in your home for 15+ years, replacement offers better long-term value despite higher initial costs.
Complete Style Change
Moving from traditional raised panels to contemporary flat doors, or vice versa, requires replacement. Wrapping can't change fundamental door architecture.
Kitchen Layout Changes
If you're altering cabinet sizes or configurations, replacement doors can be made to new dimensions. Wrapped doors are stuck with original sizes.
The family in Beeston wanted to modernise their traditional kitchen completely. Replacement with handleless doors and soft-close mechanisms transformed both appearance and functionality.
Budget Planning Strategies
Upfront Cost Comparison
Wrapping budget: £1,200-2,500 for average kitchen Replacement budget: £3,500-7,000 for comparable quality
The difference is significant, but so is the performance gap over time.
Cost Per Year Analysis
Wrapping lasting 8 years: £150-310 per year Replacement lasting 20 years: £175-350 per year
When calculated annually, the cost difference is smaller than it initially appears.
Phased Approach Options
Start with wrapping to get immediate improvement, then replace when budget allows. The wrapping protects existing doors while you save for replacement.
Partial replacement of most visible doors (wall units) while wrapping base units. Spreads cost while maximising visual impact.
Hidden Cost Considerations
Wrapping might need additional work - new handles, edge repairs, or cabinet adjustments that weren't anticipated.
Replacement includes everything - doors, hardware, fitting, and adjustment. No hidden extras in professional packages.
Quality Guarantee Differences
Wrapping Warranties
Material warranties typically 7-10 years for premium films, but often exclude edge lifting or application defects.
Installation warranties usually 2 years covering workmanship but not material degradation.
Exclusions are common for impact damage, excessive heat exposure, or normal wear patterns.
Replacement Guarantees
Comprehensive coverage typically 10-25 years including materials, construction, and installation.
Manufacturer backing from established companies with decades of experience and financial stability.
Local support through installation companies who stand behind their work long-term.
The guarantee difference reflects confidence in long-term performance and customer satisfaction.
Our Assessment Process
Honest Condition Evaluation
We assess existing doors realistically before recommending either option. No point wrapping doors that need replacing anyway.
Structural integrity - are doors solid and properly hung? Surface condition - will vinyl adhere properly and last? Hardware condition - do existing hinges and runners work smoothly?
Budget Reality Discussion
We discuss both options honestly, including long-term costs and performance expectations. Sometimes the "expensive" option offers better value.
Lifestyle Consideration
Family usage patterns affect which option works better. High-wear family kitchens might benefit more from replacement durability.
Timeline requirements for transformation versus budget availability.
Future plans for the property and kitchen use.
Sample and Demonstration
We show examples of both wrapped and replacement doors in similar situations. Seeing real results helps decision-making enormously.
Customers can feel the quality difference and understand what each option delivers practically.
Making the Right Choice
Both wrapping and replacement can transform kitchen appearance dramatically. The right choice depends on your specific situation - budget, timeline, existing door condition, and long-term plans.
Choose wrapping when: doors are solid, budget is limited, timeline is tight, or you want specific textured finishes.
Choose replacement when: existing doors are poor, you want modern features, long-term value matters, or complete style change is needed.
Don't choose based on price alone. The cheapest option upfront isn't always the best value over time.
Most importantly, work with suppliers who offer both options and can assess your situation honestly. Beware of companies that only offer one solution - they're likely to recommend whatever they sell rather than what suits you best.
Unsure whether wrapping or replacement suits your kitchen? Call us on 0115-824-4201 for an honest assessment of your doors and options that fit your budget and needs.
Nottingham Kitchen Fitter
You're One-Stop-Shop
For Everything Kitchens
0115-824-4201